Reading the Shorter Romantic Novel Short List

A couple of weeks ago I splurged with glee over this. Libertà is sponsoring the award for the shorter romantic novel this year and the short list was out!

As it happened, I hadn’t read any of them, so added them all to my TBR list, in the full expectation of some cracking reads, when time allowed. And then life got complicated.

Cometh the Hour, Cometh the Shorter Romantic Novel

Well, make that disastrous.

There was a water leak in my road. Actually, more of a small fountain. It continued to flow for the best part of twenty-four hours. My basement flooded.

(Not for the first time. And yes, last time it was also down to the utility company which provides my water.)

Over the course of a very long, wet and cold day, I mopped and baled at least 75 litres of water. I say at least because I’m not sure how much I had mopped and baled before I started counting. My fingers turned to ice. By the time I’d warmed them up, I needed to start baling again.

shortlist for Liberta Books shorter romantic novel award 2021I felt anxious and angry and helpless. And borderline exhausted. My concentration fractured.

But lo, the Universe had Provided. For there were six of the best, sitting there waiting to take me out of myself into a world where I could shuck off anger, anxiety and weariness and luxuriate in story where things came out well.


Reading Contenders for the 2021 Shorter Romantic Novel

Regency reading woman

print courtesy of Louise Allen

You will have grasped by now that what follows is, as Jane Austen said of her teenage History of England, personal, prejudiced and, if not quite ignorant, certainly unwriterly.

Do I consider pacing, characterisation, clever plotting, elegant style?

Um, no. This is not criticism. This is the spontaneous outpouring of a grateful reader’s heart.

So, in the order of the short list, above, reading from left to right…

A Will a Wish and a Wedding by Kate Hardy

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021A classic shorter contemporary romance and so much more.

It’s about a couple of strange people I felt I knew after the first couple of pages. He is broken inside but holding it together—just. She has deep insecurities, mainly well-founded, but she still manages to fight her corner. And stays polite while she does it. (Gosh, how I hate the Feisty Feminist Heroine looking for any old excuse to go to war before winning the Brute’s Heart.) This woman has real obstacles. And tackles them.

Favourite bit?  “Flirting by nerdiness.” Congratulations to Mills and Boon for keeping the typo out there, too. Not easy.

Eye-misting moments?  I went three times.

Added bonus? Butterflies. Gorgeous!

The Day That Changed Everything by Catherine Miller

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021An intriguing mystery wrapped up with a meditation on love in many guises.

We know we’re on a mystery tour in this novel from the first page, headed “The First Love”, and the first sentence “This is the one you think will last for ever.”  Aha, you think. So this one won’t last for ever then. Well, yes and no.

Tabitha wakes up to find her husband dead beside her. (From natural causes before you set off for another dead end.) The book tells you what happens in three time zones: Then, Before Then and Now— which travels forward, as Tabitha heals and learns and makes sense of stuff that hurt her before.

I loved Tabitha. Even though I thought she was crazy quite a lot of the time, I saw that she made sense to herself. I loved her lunatic foster kids, her practical, accepting neighbours, her late husband, her Dad, her old friend and her new love.

Favourite bit? “Not everything that’s beautiful is kind.”

Eye-misting moments? Stopped counting.

Added bonus? Shooting an intrusive drone out of the sky. YES!

The Warrior Knight and the Widow by Ella Matthews

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021School of Ivanhoe, Robin Hood and The Sea Hawk, this book is as full of danger and suspense as a James Bond with added female  empowerment. We’re in mediaeval England with warring lords, the right of might, and women primarily useful as political pawns and bearers of heirs.

Ellena, widowed when her much-loved husband died, is making a pretty good fist of running her estate, when her father summons her back to his castle. An unprepossessing neighbour lord wants to marry her. Her father has another candidate in mind. And the leader of her escort back to her father’s is a dispossessed man with a fearsome reputation. Just as well, as the villainous neighbour is in hot pursuit.

Favourite bit? “What sort of imbecile attacks a sword-wielding man with a stick.”

Eye-misting moments?  2 for me, but this is as much an adventure as a love story and the edge-of-the-seat moments were fast and furious.

Added bonus? Moment when her father eventually admits Ellena does a good job running Swein. A deep , quiet sense of satisfaction, there.

Second Chance for the Single Mum by Sophie Pembroke

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021This is a complex contemporary story, where coming to terms with the past is a major challenge for the widowed heroine. It has the feel of a family saga — not just the family into which the heroine has married but the family that is Welsh rugby, too.

Gwen is a gentle soul, trying to protect her small daughter Evie and other family members too, not to mention being in borderline denial herself about the problems in her marriage before her husband died. The hero, a returning prodigal, has a bad boy past. And he doesn’t get the fatted calf from his parents, but rather arouses old resentments. Add that he is the younger brother (and fellow team member) of her late husband, and you have a minefield!  Almost to the end, you can’t see how they can possibly manage a Happy Ever After. So a huge fat smile when they do!

Favourite bit? Caerphilly Castle, Monsieur Jean Lapin (he’s the stuffed rabbit our hero brings little Evie from France)

Eye-misting moments?  just the two for me, Monsieur Lapin and that against-the-odds happy ending. Aaah!

Added bonus? Welsh rugby. Lovely stuff.

The Return of the Disappearing Duke by Lara Temple

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021This one’s a Regency, Jim, but not as we know it. Most of the action takes place in Cairo and is another story full of spies and assassins, with a thick vein of complicated family relationships and some serious forgers, tricksters and unreliable antique dealers.

It starts in full Gothic mode with a truly horrifying scene in which a courageous teenage son protects a servant girl from his religious maniac ducal father, gets seriously beaten and banished, and then runs away anyway. Phew.

Forward 22 years and we find him, by now six foot tall and impressively muscled,  shaving in an Egyptian inn, when our heroine dressed as a boy bursts in on him and ask for his help to get back to Cairo. And the way he deals with her makes me laugh. Well, he makes Cleo laugh, too. He’s a cynical, outspoken soldier of fortune, with a clear eye (he doesn’t buy the boy’s disguise for a moment), a trusted truth-telling servant, his own private demons, a good deal of kindness and absolutely no party manners at all. Love him to bits.

Favourite bit? “‘Amazingly, you did not make a fool of yourself, though I would be sure to tell you if you did.’ She glared at him. ‘That’s right,’ he approved. ‘Annoyance is healthier than embarrassment. Have at me.'”

Eye-misting moments?  Possibly two. But loads of laugh-out-loud moments

Added bonus? Well, along with all the adventure and villains and troublesome family and witty exchanges, it’s truly romantic. “I don’t know you very well, but I hate the thought of you being hurt.” Oh yes.

Cinderella and the Surgeon by Scarlet Wilson

shortlisted title for Liberta Award for Shorter Romantic Novel 2021A contemporary hospital-set story, school of Lucilla Andrews and Betty Neels, in which the protagonist nurse is also the moral heart of the story.

Esther is a sweetheart but no pushover. When a junior doctor mauls an elderly patient, stabbing away trying to get an IVF into an elderly patient rather than ask for help, she lets fly at him. The angrier she gets, the more Scottish she gets. And ends up netting the nickname Crabbie Rabbie. I really relate to that.

And aristocratic surgeon Harry hasn’t met a sweetheart before. Or much love for that matter. And he puts her back up because he’s not only posh, he’s rich. (And good at his job, which I quite see would be very galling in the circumstances.)

Favourite bit? “You were the first person that made me think I might be good enough.”

Eye-misting moments?  Pretty much the whole of the last two chapters.

Added bonus? The nursing camaraderie. This is a world I love and believe in.

Reader Satisfaction from the Shorter Romantic Novel?

hugging a tree better than writer's blockPretty damn high. Every single one of these books hits the spot in one way or another. They made me forget numb fingers, aching arms, a house that smelled of damp and was full of displaced cellar treasures and even lockdown.

Liz Fielding is absolutely right when she says that the best shorter romantic novel is like a hug.

It makes you feel human again, gives you hope. Whichever book wins, I am so, SO grateful to all these authors for that.

Sophie Weston Author


7 thoughts on “Reading the Shorter Romantic Novel Short List

  1. Liz Fielding

    I’ve recently been through a horrible reading slump. I have two books recently started on my Kindle, both with intriguing openings, that I know I will not finish. I have at least one auto buy waiting, that I can’t bring myself to open. But this post has fired me up. I want to read every one of these books so, box sets, banished, I’m about to have a “one-click” bonanza. Thank you, Sophie. And thank you to these writers.

  2. lesley2cats

    Agree about the reading slump, Liz. At one point last week i started three books in one day, all previously read and loved, and discarded all of them. Perhaps I just need a sorter romance hug.

    1. Joanna

      I think I need a shorter romance hug. Have been reading some new (to me) authors lately and have been hugely disappointed. One author (whom I won’t name) boasted of how much research she’d done for her medieval set in England. I gave up when the local peasants took out their fears of supernatural beasts by killing — would you believe? — a racoon. Yes, quite.

Comments are closed.