Tag Archives: Downton Abbey

Historical fiction: getting your aristocratic title right

Joanna is on a rant again…

Queen Victoria, coronation portrait, Sir George Hayter

Queen Victoria by George Hayter – Royal Collection RCIN 401213, Public Domain, Link

This week, I’ve been reading a historical romance set in Britain in the early Victorian period. I won’t name it, but it’s by a bestselling author. Many characters have titles. It’s full of adventure and very sexy. I enjoyed it.

BUT the bestselling author (who hails from the USA) gets one of her aristocratic titles wrong. Sadly, many do, especially if they’re not Brits. It falls, I suspect, into the pesky category of “unknown unknowns”. It may never occur to an author to check whether she is right about the title she assumes is appropriate.

I resisted the urge to throw the book at the wall. It was a library book, so I couldn’t, however tempted I might have been  😉

Ducal titles have special pitfalls

The title in question related to a dukedom. The misnamed character was the duke’s younger brother. What is the correct courtesy title for the younger brother of a duke? Continue reading →

Servants on the Page: the Downton Conundrum


Downton Abbey
 — and Upstairs, Downstairs before that — can be a bit of a curse for writers. Why? Because both show us servants, below stairs, who are human and empathetic. Because they show us relationships between upstairs and downstairs that seem respectful on both sides, even cosy. And because they aren’t always true to history.

Don’t believe me? Then let’s turn to Mrs Isabella Beeton’s Book of Household Management (1861) for advice:

A servant is not to be seated … in his master’s or mistress’s presence; nor to offer any opinion, unless asked for it; nor even to say “good night,” or “good morning,” except in reply to that salutation.  Continue reading →